Compare Exposure and Storm on the Island: Grade 9 Thesis & Quotes (AQA)
Best for: The power of nature, psychological fear, and human helplessness. If the exam poem is Exposure, compare to Storm on the Island to show how Owen presents nature as a slow, merciless executioner, while Heaney presents it as an unseen, psychological threat. If the exam poem is Storm on the Island, compare to Exposure to show how both poets strip away romantic ideas of conflict, revealing nature as a force that dwarfs human control.
Elite Thesis:
“While Owen depicts nature as a prolonged, lethal siege that physically erodes soldiers into numbness and death, Heaney presents it as an invisible, psychological aggressor that assaults the mind with fear, with both poets ultimately exposing the fragility of human defenses against elemental power.”
Quick Comparison Grid (The “Ninja Cheat Sheet”)
| Element | Exposure (Owen) | Storm on the Island (Heaney) |
|---|---|---|
| When? | WWI—endless nights in the trenches | Rural Ireland—a violent Atlantic storm |
| Key Image | “Merciless iced east winds” / “Pale flakes” | “Exploding comfortably” / “Huge nothing” |
| The Enemy | Nature itself—the wind, snow, and frost | Nature as an unseen force—wind and air |
| Tone | Numb, weary, despairing | Tense, controlled, fearful |
| Structure | Regular stanzas with cyclical refrains | One long stanza with enjambment |
| The Result | “But nothing happens”—death through neglect | “It is a huge nothing that we fear”—fear without impact |
1. Nature as the Enemy: Executioner vs Psychological Weapon
Exposure:
- Owen personifies nature as an active killer: the winds “knive us” and the snow has “fingering stealth.” The weather acts with intent and cruelty.
- The lack of a human enemy makes nature the primary antagonist, highlighting the futility of human conflict when faced with elemental forces.
- Elite Link: The “melancholy army” of dawn reframes nature as the true opposing force, suggesting that the soldiers are fighting the wrong war entirely.
Storm on the Island:
- Heaney presents nature as invisible but overwhelming: there is “no company,” only “wind” that cannot be seen but can be felt and heard.
- The use of military imagery (“bombarded,” “strafes”) shows how the speaker conceptualizes nature as an attacking force, despite no literal war.
- Elite Link: The paradox of “exploding comfortably” reflects how fear is psychological—the real damage is not physical destruction, but mental assault.
Explore: Owen shows nature as a direct executioner, while Heaney shows it as a psychological weapon—both strip away the idea that humans are in control of their environment.
2. Fear and Human Vulnerability: Numbness vs Anticipation
Exposure:
- Fear becomes numbness: repeated suffering leads to emotional and physical paralysis. “Our brains ache” suggests exhaustion rather than adrenaline.
- The soldiers’ faith erodes alongside their bodies: “For love of God seems dying,” showing that fear destroys spiritual certainty.
- Elite Link: The repetition of “But nothing happens” conveys the ultimate horror—not dramatic death, but meaningless endurance.
Storm on the Island:
- Fear is anticipatory and psychological: the community is “prepared” yet still “fearful.”
- The speaker’s language reflects anxiety rather than despair; short, blunt clauses create tension.
- Elite Link: The final line—”It is a huge nothing that we fear”—suggests fear itself is the enemy, not physical harm.
Explore: Owen presents fear as paralyzing erosion, while Heaney presents it as sustained tension—both show that nature attacks the mind as much as the body.
3. Structure: Repetition vs Continuous Pressure
Exposure:
- The regular stanza pattern and cyclical refrains mirror the endless routine of trench life.
- The ABBAC rhyme scheme and half-rhyme create unresolved tension that never settles.
- Elite Link: The poem’s circular structure reinforces the idea of entrapment—there is no escape from exposure.
Storm on the Island:
- The poem’s single stanza creates relentless momentum with no pause for relief.
- Heavy enjambment mimics the continuous battering of wind.
- Elite Link: The lack of a clear resolution mirrors the unpredictability of nature.
Explore: Owen uses structure to trap the reader in repetition, while Heaney uses structure to overwhelm the reader with pressure—both enact the power of nature through form.
Context Comparison (AO3 Power Move)
| Exposure (Owen) | Storm on the Island (Heaney) |
|---|---|
| Written in 1917 by a soldier-poet in WWI—Owen wanted to expose the “pity of war.” | Written in 1966 by a post-war poet in Ireland—Heaney explores conflict indirectly through nature. |
| Reflects trench warfare—static, prolonged suffering caused by neglect and environment. | Reflects The Troubles context metaphorically—fear of unseen violence mirrors political tension. |
| Nature replaces the human enemy, highlighting war’s futility. | Nature becomes a metaphor for unseen political and psychological threats. |
Elite Insight: Owen uses nature to reveal the meaninglessness of war, while Heaney uses it to reveal the psychology of fear—both challenge the idea that humans can dominate their world.
Exam Sentence Starters
- “While Owen presents nature as a merciless executioner that erodes soldiers through prolonged exposure, Heaney depicts it as an invisible psychological aggressor that destabilizes the mind…”
- “Both poets personify nature as a hostile force: Owen through lethal winds and frost, and Heaney through militarized imagery that transforms weather into an attack…”
- “The cyclical structure of Exposure mirrors the endless suffering of the trenches, whereas the single-stanza form of Storm on the Island creates relentless pressure without relief…”
- “Owen’s depiction of numbness contrasts with Heaney’s portrayal of anticipatory fear, yet both reveal humanity’s vulnerability in the face of elemental power…”
- “Contextually, Owen’s firsthand experience of WWI trench warfare parallels Heaney’s metaphorical exploration of political fear, as both poets strip away romantic notions of conflict…”
FAQs
What is the best poem to compare with Exposure?
Storm on the Island is excellent for the power of nature. You can also compare it to Remains for the psychological aftermath of war, or Charge of the Light Brigade for futility vs. glory.
What is the best poem to compare with Storm on the Island?
Exposure is ideal for nature as an enemy. Alternatively, compare it to The Prelude for human insignificance, or Bayonet Charge for fear and panic.
What is the best theme linking Exposure and Storm on the Island?
The Power of Nature and Human Vulnerability—both poems show that nature overwhelms human defenses, whether through slow erosion or sudden psychological assault.
What quotes should I compare between Exposure and Storm on the Island?
- “Merciless iced east winds” (Exposure) vs. “Bombarded by the empty air” (Storm)—nature as an aggressor.
- “But nothing happens” (Exposure) vs. “It is a huge nothing that we fear” (Storm)—futility vs. fear.
- “For love of God seems dying” (Exposure) vs. “We are prepared” (Storm)—loss of faith vs. fragile confidence.
How do I compare structure in Exposure and Storm on the Island?
Owen uses regular stanzas and cyclical refrains to mirror endless suffering, while Heaney uses a single, enjambed stanza to create sustained pressure. Both use form to reflect nature’s dominance.
What is a Grade 9 thesis for Exposure vs. Storm on the Island?
“While Owen depicts nature as a prolonged, lethal siege that physically erodes soldiers into numbness, Heaney presents it as an invisible psychological aggressor that assaults the mind, exposing the fragility of human defenses.”
Read Next
Download the Full Comparison Pack
Want all 15 poem comparisons in this format? Download the GCSE Ninja Elite Comparison Pack gcseninja.co.uk/comparison-pack.